ePapers Repository

Seeing things differently? The promise of qualitative longitudinal research on the third sector

Macmillan, Rob (2011) Seeing things differently? The promise of qualitative longitudinal research on the third sector. Working Paper. University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.


URL of Published Version: http://www.tsrc.ac.uk/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=yMWk1rFqay4%3d&tabid=500


There has been a rapidly growing interest in longitudinal research methods and dynamic analysis in recent decades. A longitudinal research gaze offers the promise of seeing things differently, and of understanding the dynamic processes involved in social change, of what happens next and why. This paper explores the potential of qualitative longitudinal research for developing understanding of the dynamics of the third sector. The Third Sector Research Centre has embarked upon a qualitative longitudinal study of third sector activities called ‘Real Times’. The paper sets out the thinking behind the study. As well as providing a basic description of the rationale, design and structure of ‘Real Times’, the paper discusses the methodological interest in qualitative longitudinal research in the third sector, the substantive contextual issues the third sector is experiencing as the study takes place, and some of the theoretical thinking involved in the study. In particular it discusses three theoretical ‘imaginings’ which inform the research: the different temporalities involved in the third sector; a ‘relational’ account of the third sector as a contested field; and lastly the idea of strategic action in context.

Type of Work:Monograph (Working Paper)
School/Faculty:Colleges (2008 onwards) > College of Social Sciences
Number of Pages:37
Department:Third Sector Research Centre (TSRC)

Adam, B (1990) Time and Social Theory (Cambridge, Polity Press)

Adam, B (1995) Timewatch: The Social Analysis of Time (Cambridge, Polity Press)

Alcock, P (2004) ‘The Influence of Dynamic Perspectives on Poverty Analysis and Anti-Poverty Policy in the UK’ Journal of Social Policy 33(3): 395-416

Alcock, P (2010) A strategic unity: defining the third sector in the UK Voluntary Sector Review 1(1): 5-24

Alcock, P, Harrow, J, Macmillan, R, Vincent, J and Pearson, S (1999) Making Funding Work: Funding regimes and local voluntary organisations (York, York Publishing Services)

Archer, M S (1995) Realist social theory: the morphogenetic approach (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press)

Archer, M S (1998) ‘Social Theory and the Analysis of Society’ in May, T and Williams, M (eds)(1998) Knowing the Social World (Buckingham, Open University Press), pp 69-85

Arvidson, M (2009) Impact and evaluation in the UK third sector: reviewing literature and exploring ideas (Third Sector Research Centre, TSRC Working Paper 29), December 2009

Arvidson, M, Lyon, F, McKay, S and Moro, D (2010) The ambitions and challenges of SROI (Third Sector Research Centre, TSRC Working Paper 49), December 2010

Backus, P and Clifford, D (2010) Trends in the concentration of income among charities (Centre for
Charitable Giving and Philanthropy and Third Sector Research Centre, TSRC Working Paper 39), June 2010

Berthoud, R and Burton, J (eds)(2008) In Praise of Panel Surveys (Colchester, ISER/University of Essex), September 2008

Berthoud, R and Gershuny, J (eds)(2000) Seven Years in the Lives of British Families: evidence on the dynamics of social change from the British Household Panel Survey (Bristol, Policy Press)

Billis, D (1996) ‘Who cares whether your organisation survives?’ in Billis, D & Harris, M (eds)(1996) Voluntary Agencies: Challenges of Organisation and Management (Basingstoke: Macmillan), pp 222-236

Billis, D (ed.) (2010) Hybrid Organizations and the Third Sector: Challenges for Practice, Theory and Policy (Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan)

Blackmore, A (2004) Standing apart, working together: A study of the myths and realities of voluntary and community sector independence (London, NCVO) February 2004

Blake, G, Robinson, D, and Smerdon, M (2006) Living Values: A report encouraging boldness in third sector organisations (London, Community Links and Esmée Fairburn Foundation)

Bolton, M (2002) Voluntary sector added value: a discussion paper (London, NCVO)

Bourdieu, P (1990) In Other Words (Cambridge, Polity Press)

Bourdieu, P and Wacquant, L (1992) An Invitation to Reflexive Sociology (Cambridge, Polity Press)

Buckingham, H (2009) ‘Competition and contracts in the voluntary sector: exploring the implications for homelessness service providers in Southampton’ Policy and Politics 37(2): 235-54

Burchardt, T (2000) ‘The Dynamics of Being Disabled’ Journal of Social Policy 29(4): 645-668

Burgess, S and Propper, C (2002) ‘The Dynamics of Poverty in Britain’ in Hills, J, Le Grand, J and Piachaud, D (eds)(2002) Understanding Social Exclusion (Oxford, Oxford University Press), pp.44-61

Calhoun, C (2003) ‘Pierre Bourdieu’ in Ritzer, G. (ed.) (2003) The Blackwell Companion to Major Contemporary Social Theorists (Oxford, Blackwell), pp.274-309

Cameron, D (2009) ‘The Big Society’ The Hugo Young Memorial Lecture, 10th Nov 2009, http://www.conservatives.com/News/Speeches/2009/11/David_Cameron_The_Big_Society.aspx

Carmel, E and Harlock, J (2008) Instituting the ‘third sector’ as a governable terrain: partnership, procurement and performance in the UK Policy and Politics 36(2): 155-171

Carrington, D (2005) ‘Financing the voluntary and community sector – future prospects and possibilities’ in Robb, C (ed.) (2005) Voluntary Action: meeting the challenges of the 21st century (London, NCVO), February 2005 pp. 95-119

Carrington, D (2009) Funding our Future: challenges and opportunities in the next decade (London, NCVO)

Chapman, T, Robinson, F, Brown, J, Crow, R, Bell, V and Bailey, E (2010) What makes a third sector organisation tick? Interactions of foresight, enterprise, capability and impact (Middlesbrough, Teesside University), February 2010

Charity Commission (2010) Strength in Numbers: Small charities’ experience of working together (London, Charity Commission)

Chau, V S and Witcher, B J (2005) ‘Longitudinal tracer studies: research methodology of the middle range’ British Journal of Management 16(4): 343-55

Chia, R (2002) ‘Time, Duration and Simultaneity: Rethinking Process and Change in Organizational Analysis Organization Studies 23(6): 863-868

Christensen, S and Molin, J (1995) ‘Origin and Transformation of Organizations: Institutional Analysis and the Danish Red Cross’ in Scott, W R and Christensen, S (eds) The Institutional Construction of Organisations: International and Longitudinal Studies (Thousand Oaks, Sage), pp.67-90

Craig, G, Taylor, M and Parkes, T (2004) 'Protest or Partnership? The Voluntary and Community Sectors in the Policy Process' Social Policy and Administration 38(3): 221-239

Dingwall, R (1997) ‘Accounts, Interviews and Observations’ in Miller, G and Dingwall, R (eds)(1997) Context and Method in Qualitative Research (London, Sage), pp 51-65

Elliott, J, Holland, J and Thomson, R (2009) ‘Longitudinal and Panel Studies’ in Alasuutari, P, Bickman, L and Brannen, J (2009) The Sage Handbook of Social Research Methods (London, Sage), pp.228-248

Ellwood, D (1998) ‘Dynamic Policy Making: an insider’s account of reforming US welfare’ in Leisering, L and Walker, R (eds)(1998) The Dynamics of Modern Society: poverty, policy and welfare (Bristol, Policy Press), pp 49-59

Emirbayer, M and Johnson, V (2008) ‘Bourdieu and organizational analysis’ Theory and Society 37(1): 1-44
Foley, M W and Edwards, B (1999) ‘Is it time to disinvest in social capital?’ Journal of Public Policy 19(2): 141-173
Funding Commission (2010) Funding the Future: A 10-year framework for civil society (London, NCVO)

Glasby, J. (1999) Poverty and Opportunity: 100 years of the Birmingham Settlement (Studley, Brewin Books)

Glasby, J (2001) ‘One hundred years of the Birmingham Settlement’, in R Gilchrist and T Jeffs (eds) Settlements, social change and community action: good neighbours (London, Jessica Kingsley)

Glick, W H, Huber, G P, Chet Miller, C, Doty, D H, Sutcliffe, K M (1990) ‘Studying Changes in Organizational Design and Effectiveness: Retrospective Event Histories and Periodic Assessments’ Organization Science, 1(3): 293-312

Grabher, G (2001) ‘Locating economic action: projects, networks, localities, instititions’ Environment and Planning A 33: 1329-1334

Grabher, G (2002a) 'Cool Projects, Boring Institutions: Temporary Collaboration in Social Context' Regional Studies 36(3): 205-214

Grabher, G (2002b) ‘The Project Ecology of Advertising: Tasks, Talents and Teams’ Regional Studies 36(3): 245-262

Green, H (2009a) State of the Sector Panel Survey: Introduction and Panel Characteristics (London, Cabinet Office), January 2009

Green, H (2009b) State of the Sector Panel Survey, Report 1: Activities and Funding (London, Cabinet Office), January 2009

Green, H (2009c) State of the Sector Panel Survey, Report 4: Human and Capital Resources (London, Cabinet Office), January 2009

Hassard, J (2002) ‘Organizational Time: Modern, Symbolic and Postmodern Reflections’ Organization Studies 23(6): 885-892

Hay, C (2002) Political Analysis: A Critical Introduction (Basingstoke, Palgrave)

Henderson, S, Holland, J, McGrellis, S, Sharpe, S and
Thomson, R (2007) Inventing Adulthoods: A Biographical Approach to Youth Transitions (London, Sage)

Hills, J (2002) ‘Does a Focus on ‘Social Exclusion’ Change the Policy Response?’ in Hills, J, Le Grand, J and Piachaud, D (eds)(2002) Understanding Social Exclusion (Oxford, Oxford University Press), pp 226-243

Holland, J, Thomson, R and Henderson, S (2004) Feasibility Study for a Possible Qualitative Longitudinal Study: Discussion Paper (Swindon, ESRC) Oct 2004

Holland, J, Thomson, R and Henderson, S (2006) Qualitative Longitudinal Research: A Discussion Paper (London, Families & Social Capital ESRC Research Group, London South Bank University), Dec 2006

Hopkins, A (2007) Delivering Public Services: Service users’ experiences of the third sector A report to the Office of the Third Sector by the National Consumer Council (London, National Consumer Council), April 2007

Jessop, B (1990) State Theory: putting capitalist states in their place (Cambridge,
Polity Press)

Jochum, V and Pratten, B (2009) Values into Action: how organisations translate their values into practice (London, NCVO)

Knight, B and Robson, S (2007) The Value and Independence of the Voluntary Sector (Newcastle, CENTRIS)

Lawless, P, Foden, M, Wilson, I and Beatty, C (2010) ‘Understanding Area-based Regenartion: The New Deal for Communities Programme in England’ Urban Studies 47(2): 257-275

Lawrie, A (1996) The Complete Guide to Creating and Managing New Projects for
Charities and Voluntary Organisations (London, Directory of Social Change)

Leisering, L and Leibfried, S (1999) Time and Poverty in Western Welfare States: United Germany in perspective (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press)

Leisering, L and Walker, R (eds)(1998) The Dynamics of Modern Society: poverty, policy and welfare (Bristol, Policy Press)

Leonard-Barton, D (1990) ‘A Dual Methodology for Case Studies: Synergistic Use of a Longitudinal Single Site with Replicated Multiple Sites’ Organization Science 1(3): 248-266

Lewis, J (2007) ‘Analysing Qualitative Longitudinal Research in Evaluations’ Social Policy and Society 6(4): 545-556

Lewis, D (2008) ‘Using Life Histories in Social Policy Research: The Case of Third Sector/Public Sector Boundary Crossing’ Journal of Social Policy 37(4): 559-578

Macmillan, R (1999) ‘The limits of output-related funding regimes: A biographical case study of a collapsing voluntary organisation’ Conference Proceedings of the 5th Researching the Voluntary Sector Conference, City University, 7-8 September 1999

Macmillan, R (2005) 'Taking time seriously: adding temporal depth to qualitative research in the voluntary sector' in Alcock, P and Scott, D (eds)(2005) Close work: Doing qualitative research in the voluntary sector (West Maling, Charities Aid Foundation) pp 44-45

Macmillan, R (2007) ‘Understanding the idea of ‘grant dependency’ in the voluntary and community sector’ People, Place and Policy Online, 1(1): 30-38, available at http://extra.shu.ac.uk/ppp-online/issue_1_220507/article_4.html

Macmillan, R with Batty, E, Goudie, R, Morgan, G and Pearson, S (2007) Building effective local VCS infrastructure. The characteristics of successful support for the local voluntary and community sector. Sheffield, NAVCA

Macmillan, R (forthcoming) ‘Supporting’ the voluntary sector in an age of austerity: the U.K. coalition government’s consultation on improving support for frontline civil society organisations in England Voluntary Sector Review, accepted for publication

May, J and Thrift, N (eds) (2001) TimeSpace: geographies of temporality (London, Routledge)

McLaughlin, K (2004) Towards a ‘Modernized’ Voluntary and Community Sector? Emerging lessons from government-voluntary and community sector relationships in the UK Public Management Review 6(4): 555-562

McLeod. J and Thomson, R (2009) Researching Social Change: Qualitative Approaches (London, Sage)

Mellahi, K, and Wilkinson, A (2004) Organizational Failure: A Critique of Recent Research and a Proposed Integrative Framework International Journal of Management Reviews, 5/6(1): 21–41

Milbourne, L (2009) Remodelling the Third Sector: Advancing Collaboration or Competition in Community-Based Initiatives Journal of Social Policy 38(2): 277-297

Millar, J (2007) ‘The Dynamics of Poverty and Employment: The Contribution of Qualitative Longitudinal Research to Understanding Transitions, Adaptations and Trajectories’ Social Policy and Society 6(4): 533-544

Neale, B and Flowerdew, J (2003) ‘Time, texture and childhood: the contours of qualitative longitudinal research’ International Journal of Social Research Methodology 6(3): 189-199

NICVA (2006) Positive Steps – Second Monitoring Report, September 2006 (Belfast, NICVA)

NICVA (2008) Positive Steps – Final Monitoring Report, October 2008 (Belfast, NICVA)

Office for Civil Society (2010) Supporting a Stronger Civil Society: An Office for Civil Society consultation on improving support for frontline civil society organisations (London, Cabinet Office)

Office for National Statistics (2010) Measuring Outcomes for Public Service Users (London, ONS)

Painter, J (1997) ‘Regulation, regime and practice in Urban Politics’ in Lauria, M (ed.) (1997) Reconstructing Urban Regime Theory: Regulating Urban Politics in a Global Economy (Thousand Oaks, Ca, Sage), pp 122-143

Pepin, J. (2005) Sharing without merging: A Review of Collaborative Working and Sharing Back Office Support in the Voluntary and Community Sector (London, bassac)

Pettigrew, A (1990) ‘Longitudinal Field Research on Change: Theory and Practice’ Organization Science 1(3): 267-292

Pettigrew, A (1992) ‘What is Processual Analysis?’ Scandanavian Journal of Management 13(4): 337-348

Power, A (2007) City Survivors: Bringing up children in disadvantaged neighbourhoods (Bristol, Policy Press)

Purkis, A (2010) Housing Associations in England and the Future of Voluntary Organisations (London, Baring Foundation), June 2010

Rose, D (ed.) (2000) Researching Social and Economic Change: the uses of household panel studies (London, Routledge)

Sayer, A (1992) Method in Social Science: A Realist Approach (London, Routledge), 2nd edition

Sayer, A (1999) ‘Bourdieu, Smith and disinterested judgement’ The Sociological Review 47(3): 403-31

Sayer, A (2005) The Moral Significance of Class (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press)

Schlappa, H, Pitcher, J and Cairns, B (2006) Collaborative working between large and small voluntary organisations (London, NCVO)

Scott, D, Alcock, P, Russell, L and Macmillan, R (2000) Moving Pictures: Realities of Voluntary Action (Bristol, Policy Press)

Scott, D (2010) Black boxes in the wreckage? Making sense of failure in a third sector social enterprise (Third Sector Research Centre, TSRC Working Paper 31), February 2010

Smerdon, M (ed.) (2009) The First Principle of Voluntary Action: essays on the independence of the voluntary sector from government in Canada, England, Germany, Northern Ireland, Scotland, United States of America and Wales (London, Baring Foundation), Strengthening the Voluntary Sector Working paper No.3, March 2009

Sydow, J, Lindqvist, L and DeFellippi, R (2004) ‘Project-Based Organisations: Embeddedness and Repositories of Knowledge: Editorial’ Organization Studies 25: 1475-1489

Unwin, J (2004) The Grantmaking Tango (London, Baring Foundation/Joseph Rowntree Foundation)

Walker, R (1995) ‘The Dynamics of Poverty and Social Exclusion’ in Room, G (ed.) (1995) Beyond the Threshold: the measurement and analysis of social exclusion (Bristol, Policy Press), pp 101-128

Walker, R and Leisering, L (1998) ‘New tools: towards a dynamic science of modern society’, in Leisering, L and

Walker, R (eds)(1998) The Dynamics of Modern Society: Poverty, Policy and Welfare (Bristol, Policy Press), pp 17-33

Westall, A (2009) Value and the third sector: Working paper on ideas for future research (Third Sector Research Centre, TSRC Working Paper 25), December 2009

Westall, A (2010) ‘UK government policy and ‘social investment’’ Volunta

Date:March 2011
Series/Collection Name:TSRC Working Paper Series
Keywords:Qualitative longitudinal research; third sector; time; relational account; strategic action
Subjects:H Social Sciences > H Social Sciences (General)
H Social Sciences > HV Social pathology. Social and public welfare
Related URLs:
Funders:Economic and Social Science Research Council, Office for Civil Society, Barrow Cadbury Trust
ID Code:784

Export Reference As : ASCII + BibTeX + Dublin Core + EndNote + HTML + METS + MODS + OpenURL Object + Reference Manager + Refer + RefWorks
Share this item :
QR Code for this page

Repository Staff Only: item control page