ePapers Repository

The third sector delivering public services: an evidence review

Macmillan, Rob (2010) The third sector delivering public services: an evidence review. Working Paper. University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.


URL of Published Version: http://www.tsrc.ac.uk/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=l9qruXn%2fBN8%3d&tabid=500


This paper examines research evidence, argument and policy development on the third sector and public service delivery over the last five to ten years. Forty-eight separate pieces of research published between 2004 and 2010 on the themes of public service delivery, commissioning and procurement are reviewed. This body of literature represents the research response to the new third sector public sector delivery landscape which has developed out of the UK Labour government’s interest in promoting the sector’s role in service delivery. The review examines four themes developed from the literature: emerging commissioning and procurement practices; the experiences of third sector organisations in the new service delivery landscape; the support needs of third sector organisations, and the impact of the new service delivery landscape on third sector organisations.

By examining what we think we know and suggesting priorities for ongoing research, the paper aims to contribute to the ongoing discussion of the sector’s role in service delivery. The third sector’s experience of the new service delivery landscape has been somewhat mixed and varied. But new questions will be asked about the sector’s experience in an era marked by public finance retrenchment and under different political and ideological priorities. As a ‘stock-take’ and a baseline for a new economic and political context, the review indicates where research attention has been focused, and where it hasn’t. Overall greater attention appears to have been given to the voices and concerns of staff involved in TSOs, rather than other stakeholders such as trustees, volunteers and particularly TSO members and service users. By contrast, far less research attention has been given to the nature of the services commissioned, whether new commissioning processes are leading to service improvement, and fundamentally what difference services make.

Type of Work:Monograph (Working Paper)
School/Faculty:Colleges (2008 onwards) > College of Social Sciences
Number of Pages:41
Department:Third Sector Research Centre (TSRC)

ACEVO (2003) Replacing the State? The Case for Third Sector Public Service Delivery (London, ACEVO), September 2003

ACEVO (2004) Surer Funding: The ACEVO Commission of Inquiry Report (London, ACEVO), January 2004

ACEVO (2008) Is it Time Up for Full Cost Recovery? Looking at Full Cost Recovery two years on (London, ACEVO)

Alcock, P (2010) ‘A strategic unity: defining the third sector in the UK’ Voluntary Sector Review 1(1): 5–24

Alcock, P, Brannelly, T and Ross, L (2004) Formality or Flexibility? Voluntary Sector Contracting in Social Care and Health (Birmingham, University of Birmingham), October 2004

Aldridge, N (2005) Communities in Control: The New Third Sector Agenda for Public Service Reform (London, ACEVO/Social Market Foundation)

Audit Commission (2007) Hearts and Minds: Commissioning from the Voluntary Sector (London, Audit Commission), July 2007

Backus, P and Clifford, D (2010) Trends in the Concentration of Income Among Charities (Centre for Charitable Giving and Philanthropy and Third Sector Research Centre, TSRC Working Paper 39), June 2010

Bennett, R (2008) ‘Marketing of Voluntary Organizations as Contract Providers of National and Local Government Welfare Services in the UK’ Voluntas 19:268–95

Bhutta, M (2005) Shared Aspirations: The Role of the Voluntary and Community Sector in Improving the Funding Relationship with Government (London, NCVO), June 2005

Blackmore, A, with Bush, H and Bhutta, M (2005) The Reform of Public Services: The Role of the Voluntary Sector (London, NCVO), June 2005

Blond, P (2009) The Ownership State: Restoring Excellence, Innovation and Ethos to the pubLic Services (London, NESTA), October 2009

Blunkett, D (2008) Mutual Action, Common Purpose: Empowering the Third Sector (London, Fabian Society), November 2008

Buckingham, H (2009) ‘Competition and contracts in the voluntary sector: exploring the implications for homelessness service providers in Southampton’ Policy and Politics 37(2): 235–54

Cairns, B, Harris, M and Hutchison, R (2006) Servants of the Community or Agents of Government? The role of community-based organisations and their contribution to public services delivery and civil renewal (London, IVAR), June 2006

Carmel, E and Harlock, J (2008) ‘Instituting the ‘third sector’ as a governable terrain: partnership, procurement and performance in the UK’ Policy and Politics 36(2): 155–71

Chadwick-Coule, T and Batty, E (2009) NAVCA Local Commissioning & Procurement Unit Evaluation: A Baseline Report (Sheffield, Sheffield Hallam University), September 2009

Chapman, T, Brown, J, Crow, R and Ward, J (2006) Facing the Future: A Study of the Impact of a Changing Funding Environment on the Voluntary and Community Sector in the North East of England (Middlesbrough, Social Futures Institute, Teesside University), March 2006

Chapman, T, Brown, J and Crow, R (2008) ‘Entering a brave new world? An assessment of third sector readiness to tender for the delivery of public services in the United Kingdom’ Policy Studies 29(1) March 2008: 1–17

Charity Commission (2007) Stand and Deliver: The Future for Charities Delivering Public services (London, Charity Commission), February 2007, RS15

Chew, C and Osborne, SP (2008) ‘Strategic Positioning in U.K. Charities that Provide Public Services: Implications of a New Integrating Model’ Public Money and Management 28(5): 283–90

Chew, C and Osborne, SP (2009a) ‘Identifying the Factors That Influence Positioning Strategy in U.K. Charitable Organizations that Provide Public services: Toward an Integrating Model’ Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 38(1): 29–50

Chew, C and Osborne, SP (2009b) ‘Exploring Strategic Positioning in the UK Charitable Sector: Emerging Evidence from Charitable Organizations that Provide Public Services’ British Journal of Management 20: 90–105

Clark, J, Dobbs, J, Kane, D and Wilding, K (2009) The State and the Voluntary Sector: Recent trends in Government Funding and Public Service Delivery (London, NCVO), September 2009

Clark, J, Kane, D, Wilding, K and Wilton, J (2010) The UK Civil Society Almanac 2010 (London, NCVO), April 2010

Commission on the Future of the Voluntary Sector (1996) Meeting the Challenge of Change: Voluntary Action in the 21st Century (London, NCVO)

Conservative Party (2008) A Stronger Society: Voluntary Action in the 21st Century (London, Conservative Party), June 2008

Conservative Party (2010) Building a Big Society (London, Conservative Party), March 2010

Cook, M and Monk, G (2009) Pathways through the Maze: A Guide to Procurement Law (London, NCVO and Sheffield, NAVCA), November 2009

Cooke, S (2007) Why Grants are Important for a Healthy Local VCS: A Study of Four Local Authorities' Policies (London, Finance Hub), June 2007

Cunningham, I (2008) ‘A Race to the Bottom? Exploring variations in employment conditions in the voluntary sector’ Public Administration 86(4): 1033–53

Cunningham, I and James, P (2007) False Economy? The Costs of Contracting and Workforce Insecurity in the Voluntary Sector (London, UNISON)

Cunningham, I and James, P (2009) ‘The outsourcing of social care in Britain: what does it mean for voluntary sector workers?’ Work, Employment & Society 23(2): 363–75

Davies, S (2006) Third Sector Provision of Employment-Related Services (London: Public and Commercial Services Union), June 2006

Davies, S (2008) ‘Contracting out employment services to the third and private sectors: A critique’ Critical Social Policy 28(2) May 2008: 136–64

Dickinson, H and Glasby, J (2010) The Personalisation Agenda: Implications for the Third Sector (Third Sector Research Centre, TSRC Working Paper 30), February 2010

Finance Hub (2008a) The Decline of Local Authority Grants for the Third Sector: Fact or Fiction? (London, Finance Hub), March 2008

Finance Hub (2008b) The Decline of Local Authority Grants for the Third Sector: Fact or Fiction? Case Studies (London, Finance Hub), March 2008

Finlayson, G (1994) Citizen, State and Social Welfare in Britain, 1830–1990 (Oxford, Clarendon Press)

Flynn, N (1996) 'A mixed blessing? How the contract culture works' in C Hanvey and T Philpot (eds)(1996) Sweet Charity: The Role and Workings of Voluntary Organisations (London, Routledge), pp. 58–68

Futurebuilders Evaluation Team (2008) Evaluation of Futurebuilders – Interim Report, Summary (Sheffield, CRESR, Sheffield Hallam University), April 2008

Futurebuilders Evaluation Team (2010) Futurebuilders Evaluation – Final Report (Sheffield, CRESR, Sheffield Hallam University), March 2010

Harris, B (2010) ‘Voluntary Action and the state in historical perspective’ Voluntary Sector Review 1(1): 25–40

HM Treasury (2002) The Role of the Voluntary and Community Sector in Service Delivery: A Cross Cutting Review (London, HM Treasury), September 2002

Hopkins, A (2007) Delivering Public Services: Service Users’ Experiences of the Third Sector. A Report to the Office of the Third Sector by the National Consumer Council (London, National Consumer Council), April 2007

House of Commons Public Administration Select Committee (2008) Public Services and the Third Sector: Rhetoric and Reality Eleventh Report of Session 2007–08 Volume I, (London, TSO), 9 July 2008

Improvement and Development Agency (IDeA) (2009) National Programme for Third Sector Commissioning: Phase 2 Brochure (London, Improvement and Development Agency), October 2009

IFF Research (2007) Third Sector Market Mapping (London, Department of Health), February 2007

Kendall, J (2003) The Voluntary Sector (London, Routledge)

Knight, B (1993) Voluntary Action (London, Home Office)

Le Grand, J and Bartlett, W (eds)(1993) Quasi Markets in Social Policy (Basingstoke, Macmillan)

Leman, J (2007) Frontline Hopscotch. VCS Engagement in Delivering Change for Children and Young People: A Jumpy Start or a Step Back? (Sheffield, NAVCA), April 2007

Lewis, J (1996) 'What does Contracting do to Voluntary Agencies?' in D Billis and M Harris (eds)(1996) Voluntary Agencies: Challenges of Organisation and Management (Basingstoke, Macmillan), pp. 98–112

Lewis, J. (1999) ‘Reviewing the relationship between the voluntary sector and the state in Britain in the 1990s’ Voluntas 10 (3): 155–70

Lewis, J (2005) ‘New Labour's Approach to the Voluntary Sector: Independence and the Meaning of Partnership’ Social Policy and Society 4: 121–31

Martikke, S (2008) Commissioning: Possible Greater Manchester VCS Organisations’ Experiences in Public Sector Commissioning (Manchester, GMCVO), November 2008

McLaughlin, K (2004) ‘Towards a ‘Modernized’ Voluntary and Community Sector? Emerging lessons from government–voluntary and community sector relationships in the UK’ Public Management Review 6(4): 555–62

Milbourne, L (2009) ‘Remodelling the Third Sector: Advancing Collaboration or Competition in Community-Based Initiatives’ Journal of Social Policy 38(2): 277–97

National Audit Office (2005) Working with the Third Sector (London, NAO), June 2005

National Audit Office (2007a) Local Area Agreements and the Third Sector: Public Service Delivery (London, TSO), June 2007

National Audit Office (2007b) Office of the Third Sector – Implementation of Full Cost Recovery (London, NAO), June 2007

National Audit Office (2007c) Public Funding of Large Charities (London, NAO), August 2007

National Audit Office (2009) Building the Capacity of the Third Sector (London, NAO), February 2009

NAVCA (2007) Sustaining Grants: Why Local Grant Aid is Vital for a Healthy Voluntary and Community Sector and Thriving Local Communities (Sheffield, NAVCA on behalf of 9 other national VCS agencies), June 2007

NAVCA (2009) Mapping Local Infrastructure Organisations’ Commissioning and Procurement Activity: Survey Findings NAVCA Local Commissioning and Procurement Unit (Sheffield, NAVCA)

Neitzert, E and Ryan-Collins, J (2009) A Better Return: Setting the Foundations for Intelligent Commissioning to Achieve Value for Money (London, NEF), January 2009

OCVA-Framework (2008) The Tender Subject of Tendering: Research into the Effects of Competitive Tendering of the Service Delivery Voluntary Sector in Oxfordshire (Oxford, OCVA), August 2008

Office for National Statistics (ONS) (2010) Measuring Outcomes for Public Service Users (London, ONS)

Office of the Third Sector OTS) (2006) Partnership in Public Services: An Action Plan for Third Sector Involvement (London, OTS), December 2006

Osborne, SP and McLaughlin, K (2004) ‘The cross-cutting review of the voluntary sector: Where next for local government–voluntary sector relationships?’ Regional Studies 38(5): 573–82

Osborne, SP, Chew, C and McLaughlin, K (2008) ‘The once and future pioneers? The innovative capacity of voluntary organisations and the provision of public services: A longitudinal approach’ Public Management Review 10(1): 51–70

Packwood, D (2007) Commissioning, Contracting and Service Delivery of Children’s Services in the Voluntary and Community Sector (London, VCS Engage)

Paxton, W and Pearce, N, Unwin, J and Molyneaux, P (2005) The Voluntary Sector Delivering Public Services: Transfer or Transformation? (York, Joseph Rowntree Foundation), August 2005

Rees, J (2008) Who Delivers Services? A Study of Involvement in and Attitudes to Public Service Delivery by the Voluntary and Community Sector in the North West of England (Manchester, Centre for Local Governance, University of Manchester), April 2008

Scott, D and Russell, L (2001) ‘Contracting: The experience of service delivery agencies’ in M Harris and C Rochester (eds) Voluntary Organisations and Social Policy in Britain: Perspectives on Change and Choice (Basingstoke, Palgrave), pp. 49–63

Shared Intelligence (2008a) Evaluation of the National Programme for Third Sector Commissioning: Baseline Report (London, IDeA), February 2008

Shared Intelligence (2008b) Evaluation of the National Programme for Third Sector Commissioning: Consultation with BME Third Sector Organisations (London, IDeA), June 2008

Shared Intelligence (2009) Evaluation of the National Programme for Third Sector Commissioning: Final Report (London, IDeA), May 2009

Simmons, L (2008) Contracts, Cuts and Closures: An Uncertain Future for South West Social Purpose Organisations. South West Forum Funding Survey 2008 (Exeter, South West Forum), October 2008

Smerdon, M (ed.) (2009)The First Principle of Voluntary Action: Essays on the Independence of the Voluntary Sector from Government in Canada, England, Germany, Northern Ireland, Scotland, United States of America and Wales (London, Baring Foundation), March 2009

Tanner, S (2007) Common Themes on Commissioning the VCS in Selected Local Authorities in Greater London (London, London Councils), May 2007

TPP Law (2008) Survey on Attitudes to Social Enterprise in Health and Social Care (London, TPP Law), November 2008

Unwin, J (2004) The Grantmaking Tango (London, Baring Foundation/Joseph Rowntree Foundation)

Walsh, K, Deakin, N, Smith, P, Spurgeon, P and Thomas, N (1997) Contracting for Change: Contracts in Health, Social Care and Other Local Government Services (Oxford, Oxford University Press)

Wynne, A (2008) Support for Success: Commissioning and contracting in Greater Manchester (Manchester, GMVSS Consortium), March 2008

Date:July 2010
Series/Collection Name:TSRC Working Paper Series
Keywords:Public services, contracting, commissioning, procurement.
Subjects:H Social Sciences > H Social Sciences (General)
H Social Sciences > HV Social pathology. Social and public welfare
Related URLs:
Funders:Economic and Social Science Research Council, Office for Civil Society, Barrow Cadbury Trust
ID Code:799

Export Reference As : ASCII + BibTeX + Dublin Core + EndNote + HTML + METS + MODS + OpenURL Object + Reference Manager + Refer + RefWorks
Share this item :
QR Code for this page

Repository Staff Only: item control page