ePapers Repository

Liberating the NHS: orders of change?

Millar, Ross and Snelling, Iain and Brown, Hilary (2011) Liberating the NHS: orders of change? Discussion Paper. University of Birmingham, Health Services Management Centre, Birmingham.


URL of Published Version: http://www.hsmc.bham.ac.uk/publications/policy-papers/policy-paper-eleven.pdf


Ever since the NHS White Paper was published in July 2010, debate has raged as to whether this is a revolutionary or evolutionary policy programme. At the time, the government was keen to demonstrate the radical and innovative nature of its proposals, but as opposition has increased the language seems to have changed, with policy makers stressing the way in which proposals build on previous policy.

As the Health and Social Care Bill goes to the House of Lords in forthcoming months, a policy paper from the Health Services Management Centre analyses this new reform programme. Overall, the paper suggests the reform proposals represent a large degree of continuity or evolution from previous reform agendas. However, they also raise the point that the combined impact of the reforms when implemented may have the potential to bring about radical change as the scale and speed of the proposed changes take effect. They reflect on the contextual factors likely to affect the implementation of the policy proposals and raise some practical implications for researchers and practitioners to consider in relation to this new reform agenda.

Type of Work:Monograph (Discussion Paper)
School/Faculty:Colleges (2008 onwards) > College of Social Sciences
Number of Pages:23
Department:Health Services Management Centre

Audit Commission (2006) Early lessons in implementing practice based commissioning, Audit
Commission: London.

BBC (2011) ‘‘Evolutionary’ Health and Social Care Bill launched’, Available at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/

Bevan, G. and Hood, C. (2006) ‘What’s measured is what matters: targets and gaming in the English
public health care system’, Public Administration, 84: 3, pp. 517-538.

Brereton, L. and Vasoodaven, V. (2010) The Impact of the NHS market. Civitas

Bloom, N. Propper, C. Seiler, S. Van Reenan, J. (2010) The impact of competition on management
quality: evidence from public hospitals, Centre for Economic Performance, London School of
Economics and Political Science.

Birmingham City Council (2008) Birmingham: LAA 2008-2011 Working together for a better Birmingham,

Birmingham City Council: Birmingham
British Medical Association (2009) Choose and Book:

Learning Lessons from Local Experience. BMA.

BMJ (2011) ‘Reaction: what they say about the health bill’,
BMJ, 342, pp. 413.

Christianson, J. Leatherman, S. and Sutherland, K. (2007) Financial incentives, healthcare providers,
and quality improvements. A review of the evidence. The Health Foundation.

Cooper Z, McGuire A, Jones S, Le Grand J. (2009) ‘Equity, waiting times and NHS reforms: retrospective
study’, BMJ, 339: 32, pp. 3264.

Cooper, Z. Gibbons, S. Jones, S. McGuire, A. (2010) Does hospital competition save lives? Evidence
from the English NHS patient choice reforms, London School of Economics and Political Science.

Coleman, A. Checkland, K. Harrison, S. and Dowswell, G. (2009) Practice-based Commissioning:
theory, implementation and outcome: Final report. NPCRDC, Manchester University

Cookson, R. Dusheiko, M. Hardman, G. Martin, S. (2010) ‘Does hospital competition increase health care
inequalities? Evidence from the English National Health Service 1991-2001’, Journal of Public
Administration Research and Theory. (in press)

Curry, N. Goodwin, N. Naylor, C. Robertson, R. (2008) Practice-based commissioning: reinvigorate,
replace or abandon? ,The King’s Fund: London.

Department of Health (2008) High Care Quality for All, The Stationary Office: London.

Department of Health (2009a) NHS 2010 - 2015: from good to great. Preventative, people-centred,
productive, The Stationary Office: London.

Department of Health (2009b) Transforming community services: enabling new patterns of provision,
The Stationery Office: London.

Department of Health (2010a) Equity and excellence: Liberating the NHS, The Stationery Office: London.

Department of Health (2010b) Equity and excellence:

Liberating the NHS Analytical strategy for the
White Paper and associated documents. The Stationery Office: London.

HSMC - Policy Paper 1 1 21

Department of Health (2010c) Liberating the NHS. Regulating healthcare providers: a consultation on
proposals. The Stationery Office: London.

Department of Health (2010d) Liberating the NHS Commissioning for patients: a consultation on
proposals. The Stationery Office: London.

Department of Health (2010e) Liberating the NHS: Local democratic legitimacy in health: a consultation
on proposals. The Stationery Office: London.

Department of Health (2010f) Transparency in outcomes – a framework for the NHS a consultation on
proposals. The Stationery Office: London.

Department of Health (2010g) Revision to the Operating Framework for the NHS in England 2010/11.
The Stationery Office: London.

Department of Health (2010h) The Operating Framework for the NHS in England 2010/11. The Stationery
Office: London.

Department of Health (2011) Health and Social Bill 2011: First Reading, House of Commons.

Dixon, A. (2010) ‘Purchasing health care in a cold climate’, Journal of Health Service Research and
Policy, 15: 1.

Dixon, A. Robertson, R. Appleby, J. Burge, P. Devlin, N and Magee, H. (2010) Patient choice: How
patients choose and how providers respond, King’s Fund: London.

Donabedian, A. (1966) Evaluating the Quality of Medical Care. Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly

Donabedian, A. (2003) An Introduction to Quality Assurance in Health Care. Oxford University Press,

Dusheiko, M. Goddard, M. Gravelle, H. Jacobs, R. (2008) ‘Explaining trends in concentration of healthcare
commissioning in the English NHS’, Health Economics, 17: 8, pp. 907-26.

Edwards, N. (2010) The triumph of hope over expectation – Lessons from the history of reorganisation.
NHS Confederation.

Ellins, J. and Ham, C. (2009) NHS Mutual. Engaging Staff and Aligning incentives achieve higher levels
of performance. The Nuffield Trust, London.

Faculty of Public Health (2010) Faculty of Public Health response to Equity and Excellence: Liberating
the NHS.

Forster, R. and Gabe, J. (2008) ‘Voice or choice? Patient and public involvement in the National Health
Service in England under New Labour’, International Journal of Health Services, 38: 2, pp. 333–

Fotaki, M. Roland, M. Boyd, A. McDonald, R. Scheaff, R. and Smith, L. (2008) ‘What benefits will choice
bring to patients? Literature review and assessment of implications’, Journal of Health Services
Research & Policy, 13: 3, pp. 178-84.

Foundation Trust Network (2010) Consultation Response.

Gaynor, M. S. Moreno-Serra, R. Propper, C. (2010) Death by market power: reform, competition and
patient outcomes in the National Health Service. Working paper No 16164. National Bureau of
Economic Research, 2010.

Glendinning, C. Powell, M. and Rummery, K. (eds.) (2002) Partnerships, New Labour and the Governance
of Welfare, The Policy Press: Bristol.

Goodwin, N. (2007) ‘Developing effective joint commissioning between health and social care: prospects
for the future based on lessons from the past’, Journal of Care Services Management, 1:3,

Guardian (2010) ‘Reaction to NHS shakeup: Tied up in knots or free to deliver better care?, July 12th
2010’. Available at http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2010/jul/12/nhs-reform-reaction-thinktanksunions

Guardian (2011) ‘BMA rejects NHS reforms’, Tuesday 11th March 2011. Available at: http://

Greener, I. (2007) ‘Are the assumptions underlying patients choice realistic? A review of the evidence’,
British Medical Bulletin, 83:1, pp. 249-58.

Greener, I. and Mannion, R. (2009) Patient choice in the NHS: what is the effect of choice policies on
patients and relationships in health economies? Public Money & Management 29: 2, pp. 95 -100.

Ham, C. and Smith, J. (2010) Removing the policy barriers to integrated care in England.
The Nuffield Trust.

Hall, P.A. (1993) ‘Policy paradigms, social learning and the state: the case of economic policymaking in
Britain’, Comparative Politics 25: 3, pp.275–96.

Heins, E. Price, D. Pollock, A.M. Miller, E. Mohan, J. and Shaoul, J. (2010) ‘A Review of the Evidence of
Third Sector Performance and Its Relevance for a Universal Comprehensive Health System’,
Social Policy & Society, 9:4, pp. 515–526.

House of Commons Health Committee (2008) Foundation trusts and Monitor. Sixth Report of Session
2007-08. The Stationery Office: London.

House of Commons Health Committee (2009) Patient Safety. Sixth Report of Session 2008-09. The
Stationery Office: London.

HSJ (2009) ‘MP slams ‘uncontested’ FT governor elections’, October 28th Health Services Journal, HSJ:

HSJ (2010) ‘PCTs improve commissioning performance’, 5
August 2010, Health Services Journal, HSJ:

Hughes E (2007) ‘Payment by results—a model for other diabetes healthcare systems?’, Primary Care
Diabetes , 1:2, pp. 111–113.

Hughes D, Mullen C and Vincent-Jones P. (2009). Choice vs. voice? PPI policies and the re-positioning of
the state in England and Wales. Health Expectations, 12:3, pp. 237-50.

22 HSMC - Policy Paper 11

Iacobucci, G. (2010) ‘Government reforms ‘too far too fast’, warns King’s Fund’, 7th October 2010, Pulse.
Available at: http://www.pulsetoday.co.uk/story.asp?storycode=4127303

Jones, L. and Mays, N. (2009) Systematic review of the impact of patient choice of provider in the
English NHS. London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine: London

Kaplan, R. S. Norton, D. P. (1992) ‘The Balanced Scorecard – Measures that drive performance’. Harvard
Business Review, 70:1, pp. 71-79.

Klein, R. (2010) The New Politics of the NHS: From Creation to Reinvention, Radcliffe Publishing Ltd (6th
ed), Oxford.

Khunti, K. Gadsby, R. Millett, C. Majeed, A. and Davies, M. (2007) ‘Quality of diabetes care in the UK:
comparison of published quality-of-care reports with results of the Quality and Outcomes Framework
for Diabetes’, Diabetic Medicine, 24:12, pp. 1436-41

Le Grand, J. (2011) ‘Cameron’s NHS reform is no health revolution’, Financial Times, January 19th 2011.
Available at: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/43c4e79e-241b-11e0-a89a-00144feab49a.html

Lewis, R. Smith, J. Harrison, A. (2009) ‘From quasi-market to market in the National Health Service in
England: what does this mean for the purchasing of health services?’, Journal of Health Services
Research & Policy, 14:1, pp. 44-51.

Local Government Group (2010) Equity and Excellence: Liberating the NHS. Local Government Group

Mant, J. Hicks, N. (1995) ‘Detecting differences in the quality of care: the sensitivity of measures of
process and outcome in treating acute myocardial infarction’, British Medical Journal, 311, pp.

Monitor (2007) About Monitor. Effective regulation, better patient care.
NHS Confederation (2010). Consultation Response from the NHS Confederation.
NICE (2010) http://www.nice.org.uk/aboutnice/qualitystandards/qualitystandards.jsp. Last accessed 4/

Powell, M. Millar, R. Mulla, A. Brown, H. Fewtrell, C. McLeod, H. Goodwin, N. Dixon, A and Naylor, C.
(2010) Comparative case studies of health reform in England. Draft report submitted to the
Department of Health Policy Research Programme (PRP).

Propper, C. Sutton, M. Whitnall, C. and Windmeijer, F. (2008a) ‘Did ‘Targets and Terror’ Reduce Waiting
Times in England for Hospital Care?,’ The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy: 8: 2, Article

Propper, C. Burgess, S. Gossage, D. (2008b) ‘Competition and Quality. Evidence from the English NHS
internal market 1991-99’, Economic Journal, 118: 525, pp. 138-170

Rashid, M. Abeysundra, L. Mohd-Isa, A. Khan, Y. Sismeiro, C. (2007) ‘Two years and 196 million pounds
later: where is Choose and Book?’, Informatics In Primary Care, 15: 2, pp. 111-9.

Rosen, R. Florin, D. Hutt, R. (2007) An Anatomy of GP Referral Decisions: A qualitative study of GPs’
views on their role in supporting patient choice. The King’s Fund: London.

Rubin, H. R., Pronovost, P. & Diette, G. B. (2001) ‘The advantages and disadvantages of process-based
measures of health care quality’, International Journal for Quality in Health Care, 13: 6, pp. 469-

Smith, J., Mays, N., Dixon, J., Goodwin, N., Lewis, R., McClelland, S., McLeod, H. and Wyke, S. (2004) A
Review of the Effectiveness of Primary Care-led Commissioning and its Place in the NHS. The
Health Foundation

Sullivan, H. and Skelcher, C. (2002) Working Across Boundaries. Palgrave: London.

Vincent-Jones, P., Hughes, D. and Mullen, C. (2009) ‘New Labour’s PPI Reforms: Patient and Public
Involvement in Healthcare Governance?’, Modern Law Review, 72: 2, pp. 2.

Date:April 2011
Series/Collection Name:HSMC Policy Papers
Keywords:NHS Reform
Subjects:H Social Sciences > HV Social pathology. Social and public welfare
Related URLs:
ID Code:806

Export Reference As : ASCII + BibTeX + Dublin Core + EndNote + HTML + METS + MODS + OpenURL Object + Reference Manager + Refer + RefWorks
Share this item :
QR Code for this page

Repository Staff Only: item control page